How to pick an editor

Stack of books

 

 

Congratulations; you’ve completed your manuscript! The first step in becoming a published author has been reached successfully. Now you’re considering hiring a freelance editor to take a look and work through any technical errors. How do you pick an editor?

Finding the one

Finding an editor is a very personal process. Only you can know what you are looking for in an editor. Many writers spend years on a manuscript, and they want to find someone they will be able to trust with their “baby.” Some of the things to take into consideration when hiring an editor is the financial investment, the professional experience of the editor, and the personality of the editor.

First thing

One of the first things to consider when looking for an editor, is how much of a financial investment you are willing to put into your manuscript. Most of the writers seeking freelance editors are planning on going the self-publication route. They typically don’t have a lot of disposable income, and editing can be costly. If your goal in publication is monetary, then you might be more willing to put money into a manuscript you believe will pay back in time. If your goal in publication is simply to get the story out into the world, you might be less willing to put a lot of money into editing. You might be more interested in getting a few friends to read over the manuscript for free, rather than hiring a professional.

Another consideration

Another item for consideration is the professional experience of the editor. There are many freelance editors out there who have been doing it a long time – many have experience working directly in the publishing industry – while there are still others who are just starting out. Like any job, they are looking for a few people to give them a chance to gain the experience needed. There are pros and cons with either end of the spectrum. Lack of professional experience doesn’t always equal poor quality editing. One thing you can consider, is asking the editor to provide you with a sample edit. Many will offer a sample edit of a short piece provided to them – for little or no cost. This will give you an idea on the quality of work the editor can provide, as well as an idea of what to expect from that specific editor.

Trust is important

When you are trusting your manuscript to an editor, you must feel comfortable with that person. This is why it can sometimes be important to strike up a conversation with the editor, to get a feel for his or her personality. You must determine how much of a personal relationship you would like with your editor. Do you want someone you can feel comfortable talking to on a personal level, or someone who operates on a business relationship only? Do you want someone who will give feedback throughout the project, or only at the completion of the project? Do you want someone with a heavy background in the genre of your manuscript, or someone who has edited a little bit of everything?

Only you can know for sure what you want in an editor. Some writers want a person they can form a relationship with, someone who might be available to edit future projects as well. Some want an editor who will take the manuscript, edit it, and make little to no other contact. The first step for you, as the writer, is to sit down and consider what your expectations are in the editing process. Then you can go about researching a few editors to see what strikes your fancy. Send the editor an email asking about his process, or request a sample edit. Hire him to edit just a short fiction story, so you can better understand his process and you can understand what your own expectations are.

Finding an editor doesn’t have to be stressful or confusing. There is someone out there who will work well with you; you just have to understand your own expectations first.


PhotobucketRoxanne is a single mother to a 5-year-old superhero, living in the biggest little city and blogging all about her journey at Unintentionally Brilliant. She works as a freelance editor, Tupperware consultant, and administrative assistant. She is also an editor and contributing writer at World Moms Blog. When not working like a crazy woman, she enjoy walking on curbs like they are tightropes, flying with her jacket stretched out like wings, and watching every superhero movie ever made at least twenty times in a row.

 

So I Wrote A Book; Now What?

In November, 2011, I finished the first draft of my first novel.  I was excited.  I was sad.  I was scared.  I was excited because, hey!  I finished my first novel.  I was sad because after working on the manuscript for two years I had gotten to know my characters, spent many, many hours of quality time with them and they had become my friends.

And I was scared because, like so many writers who finish their first novel, I had no idea what to do next.  All I knew for sure was, “I want to publish this book!”

Now what is next?

Not knowing what to do, I started searching for advice on-line reading up on what to do next.  I knew the manuscript wasn’t ready for submission, but that was among my next steps.  And the advice I read scared me.  Everyone talks about having a large social network to whom you can promote your own book.  I don’t have a large social network.  Everyone talks about sending query letters to agents.  I don’t know what a query letter is, let alone where to find agents.  And of course, common sense tells me that my manuscript needs to be pretty damn near perfect before I submit it to anyone.  I think it’s pretty great, but who’s to say that other people will?

And now “they” read it

So I set about finding people to read my manuscript, knowing that I might be less than thrilled with the feedback I got and knowing that I needed to have at least some feedback from a specific type of audience which may be harder to find than I might like.  I gave my finished manuscript to three or four personal friends and asked them to read it and give me their honest feedback.

Find people like me?

Earlier this year, on the advice of a friend of a friend, I began a writing workshop in which I can submit up to 75 pages over three separate submissions to have the group read and critique.  It’s been interesting and beneficial, but somewhat disappointing as well.  Since my manuscript is 418 pages and the participants are only seeing 25 pages at a time, it’s hard for them to get a full picture of what I’ve created and how it all ties together.  I’ve learned a lot from the group though and I believe my revisions will be valuable.

Now I just have to figure out what my query letters should include and to whom I should send them.  My one and only goal for 2012 is to publish this book and I intend to do my very best to make that happen.


E. S. Kelly is a blogger and aspiring writer living in the San Francisco Bay Area.  He’s a big fan of all things Superman and works as Emergency Response Coordinator and safety know-it-all.  When he’s not busy saving the day, he’s the human to a 20 year old feline and mentor with Big Brothers and Big Sisters of America.  E.S and his Little Brother are big movie buffs and can usually be found on Sunday afternoons at a local cinema.